
6 October 2026
Root Canal or Extraction? How to Decide
By the team at Bollington Dental Practice, under the clinical direction of Dr Ellie Burrows, Principal Dentist. Updated October 2026.
Being told a tooth needs either root canal treatment or removal often comes at the worst moment, when it is aching and you want the problem gone. It is tempting to pick whichever sounds quicker or cheaper on the day. Both are reasonable treatments, and neither is the wrong answer in every case, but they lead to quite different places over the following years. Knowing what each involves, what it costs over time and when a tooth simply cannot be saved makes the conversation with your dentist much easier.
The short answer
If a tooth is sound enough to restore, keeping it with root canal treatment is usually the better long-term choice, because nothing replaces your own tooth quite as well. Here root canal treatment starts from £305, and many back teeth then need a crown, from £600. Extraction is quicker and costs less on the day, from £126, but the gap it leaves usually needs replacing, and replacement generally costs more than saving the tooth. If a tooth is cracked through the root or too broken down to rebuild, removal may genuinely be the right call, and your dentist will advise what suits you.
What each option involves
Root canal treatment removes the inflamed or infected pulp from inside the tooth, cleans and disinfects the canals in its roots, and seals them. It is done under local anaesthetic over one or two visits, and most people find it feels much like a long filling. A root-filled back tooth is more brittle than it was, so a crown is commonly advised to stop it cracking under chewing force. Our guide to what root canal treatment involves walks through each step.
Extraction takes the tooth out, also under local anaesthetic, usually in a single visit. The socket heals over the following weeks, and the bone underneath continues to reshape for some months.
What there is not, once the pulp is beyond recovery, is a safe third option of leaving the tooth alone. The pain may stop, but a dead pulp can go on to cause an abscess, sometimes without much warning. Antibiotics can help when infection is spreading, but they cannot reach the inside of a dead tooth, so they do not deal with the cause.
Weighing it up: the questions that matter
Can the tooth be restored? This is the first question your dentist answers, usually with an examination and an X-ray. A tooth needs enough sound structure above and around the gum to hold a filling or crown. Decay that has gone deep below the gum line, a crack that runs down into the root, or very little remaining tooth can all mean that root canal treatment would be work on a tooth that will not last.
How healthy are the gums and bone? A tooth held in place by healthy bone is a good candidate for saving. If advanced gum disease has already removed much of the bone support and the tooth is loose, saving the inside of it does not fix the outside, and extraction may be more sensible.
Where is the tooth, and what does it do? A front tooth that shows when you smile, or a back tooth that does much of your chewing, is usually worth more effort to keep. A wisdom tooth with no opposing tooth to bite against is a different matter, and removal is often the simpler path.
What would replace it? Removing a tooth is quick, but the gap has knock-on effects. Neighbouring teeth can drift and tilt into the space, the tooth above or below can over-erupt, and food can start to trap in new places. Some gaps at the very back cause few problems and can be left. Others are worth filling. Our guide to options for a missing tooth compares implants, bridges and dentures in detail.
Your health and your circumstances. Some medical histories change the balance. Certain medicines used for bone conditions, and previous radiotherapy to the head and neck, can make extraction carry more risk, which may favour keeping a tooth where possible. Equally, if several appointments are hard for you to manage, that is a fair thing to raise. Tell your dentist about your medical history and medicines, and they will factor it in.
How you feel about it. Some people strongly want to keep every tooth they can. Others would rather have a problem tooth out and move on. Both are reasonable starting points, as long as the decision is made with the full picture of what comes next.
The cost over time
The fairest comparison is not the bill on the day but the total cost of where each choice leaves you. Every figure below is from our published fees page.
- Keeping the tooth: root canal treatment from £305, plus a crown from £600 for most back teeth. Where very little tooth is left, a post and core, from £99.75, may be needed to anchor the crown. Front teeth often need only a filling afterwards. Our root canal cost guide explains what affects the price.
- Removing the tooth: extraction from £126. Our extraction cost guide covers this in more depth.
- Replacing the tooth afterwards: a single implant and restoration from £3,000, after an implant consultation at £180. A bridge costs £1,175 for two units or £1,850 for three. A partial denture is planned individually, so ask us for a price.
Put side by side, saving a restorable tooth usually costs less than taking it out and replacing it well. Extraction only becomes the cheaper route overall if the gap is one you are happy to leave. That is sometimes a perfectly sensible choice, particularly for a back tooth, and your dentist can tell you honestly whether the space is likely to cause problems.
For NHS patients, root canal treatment and extraction both fall under Band 2 in England, currently £76.60 for the course of treatment, and a crown falls under Band 3, £332.10. Our guide to NHS dental charges explains how the bands work. We are not able to take on new adult NHS patients, so the prices quoted from our fees page are for private care here.
When a tooth cannot be saved
Root canal treatment succeeds in most cases, but it is not the right tool for every tooth. Extraction is usually advised when:
- The root is cracked or split. A vertical root fracture cannot be sealed, and the tooth will keep causing trouble.
- Too little tooth remains to support a filling or crown, even with a post.
- Decay extends well below the gum and bone, so the edges of any restoration could not be kept clean.
- The tooth is very loose because gum disease has destroyed its support.
- Previous root canal treatment has failed and retreatment is unlikely to succeed. Sometimes a tooth can be retreated or referred for further root treatment, and sometimes removal is the more realistic option. Your dentist will explain which applies.
If any of these apply, your dentist will say so plainly rather than recommend treatment that is unlikely to last.
When to get urgent help
A tooth that needs root canal treatment or removal is often infected. Call us on the same day if you have a throbbing toothache, a swelling on the gum, a bad taste or a raised temperature. We offer same-day appointments where possible during opening hours. Outside those hours, call NHS 111. If swelling spreads across your face, closes your eye, or makes it hard to swallow or breathe, call 999 or go to A&E straight away. Our guide to dental abscesses explains the warning signs.
If you live in or around Macclesfield, our dentist in Macclesfield page explains how to join the practice, our fees and how to find us.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to have a root canal or an extraction?
For a tooth that can be restored, root canal treatment is usually the better long-term choice because it keeps your own tooth. Extraction makes more sense when a tooth is cracked through the root, too broken down to rebuild, or very loose from gum disease. Your dentist will examine the tooth and take an X-ray before advising what suits you.
Is an extraction cheaper than a root canal?
On the day, yes. Here extraction starts from £126 and root canal treatment from £305, often with a crown from £600. But if you want the gap filled, an implant from £3,000 or a two-unit bridge at £1,175 usually makes extraction the more expensive route overall.
Can I have a tooth out and decide about replacing it later?
Yes. Many people do, and some gaps at the back of the mouth never need filling. Bear in mind that neighbouring teeth can drift into the space over time, which can make some replacements harder later, so it is worth discussing your likely plan before the tooth comes out.
Does a root canal hurt more than an extraction?
Both are carried out under local anaesthetic, and most people feel pressure rather than pain during either. Root canal treatment takes longer in the chair. Afterwards, both commonly leave the area tender for a few days, which usually settles with over-the-counter painkillers taken as directed on the pack.
Not sure which way to go?
If you have been told a tooth needs root canal treatment or removal, or you are not sure what your options are, we can examine it and talk you through both honestly, with the costs set out before anything starts. Call 01625 574609. New patient examinations are £89 including X-rays, and every treatment price is on our fees page.
Back to Blog

